Week 4 discussion
kiace1
please read carefully and see bottom for the week’s reading
Reading short stories can provide us an opportunity to explore the structure of prose writing. For instance, a writer of prose may use elements of plot, character, or setting to create a compelling insight into the human condition.
To prepare for this discussion, be sure to complete all of the readings.
<ol>
Class READING
How Do We Read and Understand Short Stories?
Short stories have three main elements: plot, characters, and setting. We bring a set of expectations about the arrangement of these elements when we read stories. We expect the plot to have a clear beginning, middle, and end. We expect setting details and background information on the characters to be introduced in the beginning, the main character to be engaged in a conflict in the middle, and the conflict to be resolved in some way by the end. Traditionally stories have followed this pattern. Contemporary authors, however, often diverge from tradition and experiment with ways to make story construction more closely reflect their individual points of view. Their fiction challenges our expectations by beginning a story in the middle (in medias res), avoiding a clear resolution of the conflict, or disrupting convention in other ways. Whether authors follow or diverge from traditional story and character development, they must carefully arrange the elements of the story into a unified whole in order to convey meaning.
Literary Terms for Week 4: Fiction (see also "setting" and "tone" in Learning Resources for poetry in week 2)
- fiction
- short story
- plot
- exposition
- antagonist:
- the character or force (nature, society, self) that creates conflict with the main character
- protagonist:
- the main character
- conflict:
- a problem that arises for the main character
- rising action:
- the point in the story when conflict is introduced
- climax:
- the turning point in the story when the tension from the conflict is at its peak
- falling action:
- the action that occurs after the climax as tensions lessen
- resolution/denouement:
- an outcome that ends the conflict, either finally or temporarily
- in medias res
- characterization
- narrator
- narration
- narrative
- point of view
- style
Reading "The Yellow Wallpaper"
Charlotte Perkins Gilman's "The Yellow Wallpaper"
Self Study Questions
Before you read the student's responses below, note your own reaction to the story. How would you characterize the relationship between the narrator and her husband? What happens to the narrator? After a second reading, start to examine the elements of the story as you think about its meaning. Answer the following questions on a separate sheet of paper and then click on the link to see possible responses.
<ol>
A Student's Response
Let's take a look at how one student recorded her thoughts about the story and discovered a thesis. Note that the student responses are real and have not been edited for grammar or word choice. The responses represent stages that good writers take to ensure that their final essay is thoughtful and well developed.
First Reading, Student Response
I really liked this story! I felt sorry for the narrator, but wondered why she just didn't stand up to her husband and tell him off. After thinking about it some more, I realized that most women let their husbands rule their lives during that period. And her husband is a doctor, so she thought he knew the right thing to do. I'm not sure what happens at the end of the story though. It's obvious she has lost touch with reality, but why is she crawling around the room?
Faculty Comments
I'm glad you liked the story, Theresa. It's one of my favorites! You are right to point out that attitudes toward male and female roles were different in 1892 when the story was written. Knowing the historical background of the work helps us come to a better understanding of character motivation. Reread the story, noting the narrator's response to the wallpaper to see if you can determine what happens to her at the end of the story—why she acts the way that she does.
Second Reading, Student Response
Her husband thinks he knows what is best for her, but he's contributing to her depression by not allowing her any creative outlets. On the surface, she goes along with what he says, but she rebels by writing in her journal, which he has forbidden. She hides the journal from him though.
She slowly goes crazy in that room. She begins to see trapped women in the wallpaper, women like her who have been imprisoned by gender roles. The wallpaper becomes symbolic in that way. The color yellow is probably also symbolic.
The narration is very limited. We only get her point of view, which actually works well because we get to see inside of her head as she slowly loses her sanity. The ending is ironic. In one way she is free now. She has pulled off the wallpaper, liberated the women inside of it along with herself. She no longer obeys John's orders anymore. But she had to lose her mind to gain her freedom.
Faculty Comments
You've made insightful points about the narrator's rebellion through her writing and her vision of the wallpaper. Think about what actually causes the narrator to lose her sanity. How does the yellow wallpaper tie into her descent into madness? Does her rebellion have an effect on her sanity?
Once you have completed reviewing and studying the learning resources for Week 4, proceed to the discussion where you will complete an activity on it.
Read:
Kate Chopin's "The Story of an Hour"
Edgar Allan Poe's "The Tell-Tale Heart"



